.. SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-2.0

=================================
Open Firmware Devicetree Unittest
=================================

Author: Gaurav Minocha <gaurav.minocha.os@gmail.com>

1. Introduction
===============

This document explains how the test data required for executing OF unittest
is attached to the live tree dynamically, independent of the machine's
architecture.

It is recommended to read the following documents before moving ahead.

(1) Documentation/devicetree/usage-model.rst
(2) http://www.devicetree.org/Device_Tree_Usage

OF Selftest has been designed to test the interface (include/linux/of.h)
provided to device driver developers to fetch the device information..etc.
from the unflattened device tree data structure. This interface is used by
most of the device drivers in various use cases.


2. Verbose Output (EXPECT)
==========================

If unittest detects a problem it will print a warning or error message to
the console.  Unittest also triggers warning and error messages from other
kernel code as a result of intentionally bad unittest data.  This has led
to confusion as to whether the triggered messages are an expected result
of a test or whether there is a real problem that is independent of unittest.

'EXPECT \ : text' (begin) and 'EXPECT / : text' (end) messages have been
added to unittest to report that a warning or error is expected.  The
begin is printed before triggering the warning or error, and the end is
printed after triggering the warning or error.

The EXPECT messages result in very noisy console messages that are difficult
to read.  The script scripts/dtc/of_unittest_expect was created to filter
this verbosity and highlight mismatches between triggered warnings and
errors vs expected warnings and errors.  More information is available
from 'scripts/dtc/of_unittest_expect --help'.


3. Test-data
============

The Device Tree Source file (drivers/of/unittest-data/testcases.dts) contains
the test data required for executing the unit tests automated in
drivers/of/unittest.c. See the content of the folder::

    drivers/of/unittest-data/tests-*.dtsi

for the Device Tree Source Include files (.dtsi) included in testcases.dts.

When the kernel is build with CONFIG_OF_UNITTEST enabled, then the following make
rule::

    $(obj)/%.dtb: $(src)/%.dts FORCE
	    $(call if_changed_dep, dtc)

is used to compile the DT source file (testcases.dts) into a binary blob
(testcases.dtb), also referred as flattened DT.

After that, using the following rule the binary blob above is wrapped as an
assembly file (testcases.dtb.S)::

    $(obj)/%.dtb.S: $(obj)/%.dtb
	    $(call cmd, dt_S_dtb)

The assembly file is compiled into an object file (testcases.dtb.o), and is
linked into the kernel image.


3.1. Adding the test data
-------------------------

Un-flattened device tree structure:

Un-flattened device tree consists of connected device_node(s) in form of a tree
structure described below::

    // following struct members are used to construct the tree
    struct device_node {
	...
	struct  device_node *parent;
	struct  device_node *child;
	struct  device_node *sibling;
	...
    };

Figure 1, describes a generic structure of machine's un-flattened device tree
considering only child and sibling pointers. There exists another pointer,
``*parent``, that is used to traverse the tree in the reverse direction. So, at
a particular level the child node and all the sibling nodes will have a parent
pointer pointing to a common node (e.g. child1, sibling2, sibling3, sibling4's
parent points to root node)::

    root ('/')
    |
    child1 -> sibling2 -> sibling3 -> sibling4 -> null
    |         |           |           |
    |         |           |          null
    |         |           |
    |         |        child31 -> sibling32 -> null
    |         |           |          |
    |         |          null       null
    |         |
    |      child21 -> sibling22 -> sibling23 -> null
    |         |          |            |
    |        null       null         null
    |
    child11 -> sibling12 -> sibling13 -> sibling14 -> null
    |           |           |            |
    |           |           |           null
    |           |           |
    null        null       child131 -> null
			    |
			    null

Figure 1: Generic structure of un-flattened device tree


Before executing OF unittest, it is required to attach the test data to
machine's device tree (if present). So, when selftest_data_add() is called,
at first it reads the flattened device tree data linked into the kernel image
via the following kernel symbols::

    __dtb_testcases_begin - address marking the start of test data blob
    __dtb_testcases_end   - address marking the end of test data blob

Secondly, it calls of_fdt_unflatten_tree() to unflatten the flattened
blob. And finally, if the machine's device tree (i.e live tree) is present,
then it attaches the unflattened test data tree to the live tree, else it
attaches itself as a live device tree.

attach_node_and_children() uses of_attach_node() to attach the nodes into the
live tree as explained below. To explain the same, the test data tree described
in Figure 2 is attached to the live tree described in Figure 1::

    root ('/')
	|
    testcase-data
	|
    test-child0 -> test-sibling1 -> test-sibling2 -> test-sibling3 -> null
	|               |                |                |
    test-child01      null             null             null


Figure 2: Example test data tree to be attached to live tree.

According to the scenario above, the live tree is already present so it isn't
required to attach the root('/') node. All other nodes are attached by calling
of_attach_node() on each node.

In the function of_attach_node(), the new node is attached as the child of the
given parent in live tree. But, if parent already has a child then the new node
replaces the current child and turns it into its sibling. So, when the testcase
data node is attached to the live tree above (Figure 1), the final structure is
as shown in Figure 3::

    root ('/')
    |
    testcase-data -> child1 -> sibling2 -> sibling3 -> sibling4 -> null
    |               |          |           |           |
    (...)             |          |           |          null
		    |          |         child31 -> sibling32 -> null
		    |          |           |           |
		    |          |          null        null
		    |          |
		    |        child21 -> sibling22 -> sibling23 -> null
		    |          |           |            |
		    |         null        null         null
		    |
		    child11 -> sibling12 -> sibling13 -> sibling14 -> null
		    |          |            |            |
		    null       null          |           null
					    |
					    child131 -> null
					    |
					    null
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------

    root ('/')
    |
    testcase-data -> child1 -> sibling2 -> sibling3 -> sibling4 -> null
    |               |          |           |           |
    |             (...)      (...)       (...)        null
    |
    test-sibling3 -> test-sibling2 -> test-sibling1 -> test-child0 -> null
    |                |                   |                |
    null             null                null         test-child01


Figure 3: Live device tree structure after attaching the testcase-data.


Astute readers would have noticed that test-child0 node becomes the last
sibling compared to the earlier structure (Figure 2). After attaching first
test-child0 the test-sibling1 is attached that pushes the child node
(i.e. test-child0) to become a sibling and makes itself a child node,
as mentioned above.

If a duplicate node is found (i.e. if a node with same full_name property is
already present in the live tree), then the node isn't attached rather its
properties are updated to the live tree's node by calling the function
update_node_properties().


3.2. Removing the test data
---------------------------

Once the test case execution is complete, selftest_data_remove is called in
order to remove the device nodes attached initially (first the leaf nodes are
detached and then moving up the parent nodes are removed, and eventually the
whole tree). selftest_data_remove() calls detach_node_and_children() that uses
of_detach_node() to detach the nodes from the live device tree.

To detach a node, of_detach_node() either updates the child pointer of given
node's parent to its sibling or attaches the previous sibling to the given
node's sibling, as appropriate. That is it :)